Complaints Outcomes

Search

Search Results

Search Again
Li, Jin Tong (Apr 13, 2018)
 

Jin Tong (Tom) Li has completed a term of suspension which ended on April 13, 2018, and his registration as a pharmacist has been reinstated. The registrant is limited from being a manager, director, or owner of a pharmacy, hold shares in any corporation that owns a pharmacy, and/or be a preceptor for a period of five years commencing April 14, 2018.


October 20, 2016
(April 13, 2018 – Registration reinstated)

Pursuant to s. 36(1) of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached an agreement with Jin Tong (Tom) Li (the “Registrant”) to suspend his registration as a pharmacist for 540 consecutive days, from October 20, 2016 to April 13, 2018.

The Registrant acknowledged that between January 1, 2014 and December 22, 2014, he submitted fraudulent claims to PharmaCare over the PharmaNet system on over 2400 occasions. On all occasions, the Registrant had billed a high dollar value medication on PharmaNet, then reversed the medication to manipulate PharmaCare deductibles and to effectively allow patients to receive financial benefits from PharmaCare to which they were not entitled.

The Registrant also acknowledged that between January 1, 2013 and December 31, 2014, he had been the dispensing pharmacist and/or pharmacy manager responsible for multiple practice deficiencies including dispensing quantities in large excess of what had been authorized, dispensing from invalid prescriptions, dispensing from incomplete prescriptions, dispensing prescriptions under the incorrect prescriber’s name, dispensing incorrect medications, processing blood glucose test strips on PharmaNet in large excess of what could be accounted for by wholesaler invoices, and not keeping complete patient records and prescription documentation.

Prior to reinstatement of his registration following the suspension period, the Registrant will be required to:

  • thoroughly review relevant legislative requirements and to sign a Declaration acknowledging his understanding of and compliance with the legislative requirements;
  • to meet with the Inquiry Committee to discuss his reflections on his conduct and what he has learned; and
  • to complete an ethics course at his own expense.

The Registrant will also be limited from being a manager, director, or owner of a pharmacy, hold shares in any corporation that owns a pharmacy, and/or be a preceptor for a period of five years from the date that his suspension ends (commencing April 14, 2018).

The Inquiry Committee considers this agreement necessary to protect the public, as well as send a clear message to the profession that the College does not tolerate this type of conduct. 

Berra, Patrizia (Feb 22, 2018)

Patrizia Berra has completed a term of suspension which ended on February 21, 2018, and her registration as a pharmacist has been reinstated as of February 22, 2018. 


December 18, 2017
(February 22, 2018 – Registration reinstated)

Pursuant to section 36(1) of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee of the College of Pharmacists of British Columbia (the “College”) reached an agreement by consent with pharmacist registrant Patrizia Berra (the “Registrant”) to suspend her registration as a pharmacist for a period of one month from January 22, 2018 to February 21, 2018.

A member of the public obtained a printout of her PharmaNet record and discovered that the Registrant accessed her PharmaNet record. The Registrant admitted that she did not dispense a medication, provide patient counselling or evaluate a patient’s drug usage when she accessed the patient’s PharmaNet record, and that the access was without consent.

Following investigation, the Inquiry Committee determined that the Registrant inappropriately accessed a PharmaNet record for reasons unrelated to health care and without consent, in contravention of sections 21(2) and 21(3) of the Bylaws to the Pharmacy Operations and Drug Scheduling Act, section 71 of the Bylaws to the Health Professions Act, and Standard 4 of the Code of Ethics.

The Inquiry Committee found that this constitutes a “serious matter” and that inappropriate access of personal health information compromises the public’s trust in individual registrants and the pharmacy profession as a whole. Previous complaints considered by the Inquiry Committee have found that even inadvertent and innocuous inappropriate access by a registrant is sufficient for an onerous disposition.

Therefore, the Inquiry Committee and the Registrant agree that the Registrant shall submit a fine of $1,000, suspend her registration for a period of one month, and thereafter appear before a panel of the Inquiry Committee for a verbal reprimand. A letter of reprimand shall be placed on the College register as a permanent record and the College may disclose its contents in response to inquiries regarding the status of the Registrant’s registration. The Inquiry Committee considers this agreement necessary to protect the public.

Pharmacist Registrant 12 (Jan 10, 2018)

Pharmacist Registrant 12 has satisfied all the terms of an agreement reached with the Inquiry Committee dated January 10, 2013.  Limits and conditions on pharmacist registrant’s registration as a pharmacist have now been removed. The registrant’s name has been withheld pursuant to s. 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.


July 7, 2015
(January 10, 2018 - Limits and Conditions Removed)

Pharmacist Registrant 12 has satisfied some of the terms of an agreement reached with the Inquiry Committee dated January 10, 2013. At the recommendation of the registrant’s physician, these terms have been removed. The remainder of the terms in the agreement are in effect until January 10, 2018. The registrant’s name has been withheld pursuant to s. 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.


January 10, 2013
(July 7, 2015 - Partial limits and conditions removed)

The Inquiry Committee has reinstated pharmacist registrant’s registration that had previously been suspended indefinitely on October 5, 2012. Pursuant to Section 36 of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached an agreement with pharmacist registrant to place limits and/or conditions on his registration as a pharmacist effective January 10, 2013. This agreement remains in effect until January 10, 2018. The Inquiry Committee considers the agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld pursuant to 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.


October 5, 2012
(January 10, 2013 – Registration reinstated)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to Section 36 of the Health Professions Act, has reached an agreement with pharmacist registrant to suspend his registration as a pharmacist for an indefinite period pending further decision of the Inquiry Committee. The Inquiry Committee considers the agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld pursuant to 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act

Lum, King Cheong (Steven) (Jan 1, 2018)

King Cheong (Steven) Lum has completed a term of suspension which ended on December 31, 2017, and is eligible for reinstatement of registration. Until December 31, 2022, he will be limited from being a manager, director or owner of a pharmacy, hold shares in any corporation that owns a pharmacy, and/or be a preceptor.


January 1, 2017
(January 1, 2018 – Registration reinstated)

Pursuant to s. 36(1) of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached an agreement with King Cheong (Steven) Lum (the “Registrant”) to suspend his registration as a pharmacist for 365 consecutive days, from January 1, 2017 to December 31, 2017.

In or about April 2016, while pharmacy manager, director, and owner of a pharmacy, the Registrant discovered discrepancies between the on-hand quantities and computer quantities of 47 individual molecules of narcotic and controlled drugs and 21 individual molecules of benzodiazepines at the pharmacy. The most significant discrepancies were 165,998 tablets of Ratio-Oxycocet (oxycodone/acetaminophen 5mg/325mg), 1,030 tablets of Ratio-Lenoltec No. 3 (acetaminophen/caffeine/codeine 300mg/15mg/30mg), and 17,353 tablets of Mylan-Alprazolam 2mg. The Registrant had not noticed the discrepancies for many months until April 2016, and therefore the discrepancies had not been reported to Health Canada as required.

After an investigation, it was substantiated that while the Registrant was pharmacy manager, director, and owner of a pharmacy, he failed to maintain a standard of practice of the pharmacy profession and contravened the relevant provincial and federal legislation with respect to the following:

  • Management of inventory of narcotics, controlled drugs and targeted substances under his control to prevent loss or theft, including failure to count and reconcile all narcotics, controlled drugs and targeted substances at least every three months as required by Professional Practice Policy #65;
  • Failure to maintain records of purchases, sales and remaining inventory for narcotics and other controlled drugs;
  • Failure to make timely reports of losses of narcotics and other controlled drugs to Health Canada; and
  • Failure to adhere to s. 43 of the Narcotic Control Regulations, s. G.03.012 of the Food and Drug Regulations, and s. 7(1)(b) of the Benzodiazepines and Other Targeted Substances Regulations, in that he failed to take all reasonable steps that were necessary to protect narcotics, controlled drugs and targeted substances on the premises or under his control against loss or theft or to take steps necessary to ensure their security, including failure to count and reconcile narcotics, controlled drugs and targeted substances at least every three months.

The Inquiry Committee considered that the Registrant’s serious lack of judgment constituted professional misconduct.

Prior to reinstatement of his registration following the suspension period, the Registrant will be required to:

  • thoroughly review relevant legislative requirements and to sign a Declaration acknowledging his understanding of and compliance with the legislative requirements;
  • meet with the Inquiry Committee to discuss his reflections on his conduct and what he has learned;
  • successfully pass the College’s Jurisprudence Exam; and
  • pay a $30,000 fine.

The Registrant will also be limited from being a manager, director, or owner of a pharmacy, hold shares in any corporation that owns a pharmacy, and/or be a preceptor for a period of five years from the date that his suspension ends (commencing December 31, 2017).

The Inquiry Committee considers this Agreement necessary to protect the public, as well as send a clear message to the profession that the College does not tolerate this type of conduct.


May 20, 2016
(January 1, 2017 – Registration suspended)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 35(1) of the Health Professions Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 183, for the purposes of public protection, has imposed limits and conditions on the practice of registrant King Cheong (Steven) Lum, effective May 20, 2016, pending completion of an investigation of his pharmacy practice. Until further notice, Mr. Lum has the following limits and conditions on his practice:

  1. He will be restricted from the following roles in his practice:

    1. Be an owner or manager of a pharmacy;
    2. Be a director of a corporation that owns a pharmacy; and
    3. Act as a preceptor;

     

  2. He will be restricted from doing the following in relation to narcotic and controlled drugs and substances:

    1. Placing orders; 
    2. Signing wholesaler/manufacturer invoices confirming receipt of orders, or have any sort of signing authority relating to such orders; and
    3. Conducting counts and/or reconciliation of inventory;

     

  3. Prior to the commencement of new employment at any pharmacy, he will inform every manager and employer of the pharmacy in which he gains employment of the limits and conditions on his license pursuant to this order, and will ensure that the pharmacy manager and employer submits a written statement to the College declaring their awareness of the limits and conditions and how the limits and conditions will be accommodated in the pharmacy.

The registrant was the pharmacy manager, director, and owner of a pharmacy, and did not fulfill the responsibilities of a pharmacy manager, director, and owner to operate a pharmacy that met legislative and practice standards. He had not established and/or enforced policies and procedures for inventory management and security and storage of narcotic and controlled drugs, enabling a grossly large quantity of narcotic and controlled medication to be lost and/or taken from the pharmacy and potentially diverted, causing potential harm to the public.

Lam, Alexis Vanessa (Dec 8, 2017)

Alexis Vanessa Lam has satisfied all the terms of an agreement reached with the Inquiry Committee dated May 9, 2017.  Limits and conditions on pharmacist registrant’s registration as a pharmacist have now been removed. 


May 9, 2017
(December 8, 2017 - Limits and conditions removed)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 35(1)(a) of the Health Professions Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 183, for the purposes of public protection, has imposed limits and conditions on the practice of registrant Alexis Vanessa Lam, pending completion of an investigation of her pharmacy practice. Until further notice, Ms. Lam has the following limits and conditions on her practice:

  1. Effective May 9, 2017, she will be restricted from doing the following in relation to narcotic and controlled drugs and substances:
    1. Placing and receiving orders; and
    2. Signing wholesaler/manufacturer invoices confirming receipt of orders, or have any sort of signing authority relating to such orders.

Ms. Lam has not demonstrated that she has fulfilled her responsibility as a registrant to take reasonable steps to protect narcotic and controlled drugs against loss in or from the pharmacy where she works. In addition, she has not kept accurate records regarding all purchases and sales of narcotic and controlled drugs. This has enabled a large quantity of narcotic and controlled drugs at the pharmacy to be unaccounted for, causing potential harm to the public.

Pharmacist Registrant 4 (Nov 23, 2017)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 36 of the Health Professions Act, has reached an Agreement with the pharmacist registrant to voluntarily suspend the registration as a pharmacist effective November 23, 2017. The Agreement remains in effect until further notice. The Inquiry Committee considers the Agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld pursuant to section 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.


February 20, 2015
(November 23, 2017 - Registration Suspended)

Pharmacist Registrant 4 has satisfied the terms of an agreement reached with the Inquiry Committee dated April 1, 2010. Limits and conditions on pharmacist registrant’s registration as a pharmacist have now been removed. The pharmacist registrant’s name has been withheld pursuant to 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.


April 1, 2010
(February 20, 2015 - Limits and conditions removed)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to Section 36 of the Health Professions Act, has reached an agreement with pharmacist registrant to place limits and/or conditions on his registration as a pharmacist effective April 1, 2010. The agreement remains in effect until further notice. The Inquiry Committee considers the agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld pursuant to 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.

Robertson, Chadwick Aaron (Nov 22, 2017)

On a series of occasions during 2015, Chadwick Aaron Robertson (the “Registrant”) made comments to LC, an individual posing as an athlete, about the use of banned drugs and their suitability for the purpose. The Registrant provided LC a training protocol that was never put into operation. Unbeknownst to the Registrant, LC was part of an “undercover” investigation and the Registrant’s meetings and other dealings with LC were being videotaped. An edited version of the footage was ultimately broadcast over the Internet.  The College considers, and the Registrant concedes, that this conduct reflected negatively on the Registrant and the profession of pharmacy in British Columbia. It constitutes professional misconduct, a serious matter pursuant to section 26 of the Health Professions Act

For the above conduct, pursuant to section 36(1) of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached a consent agreement with the Registrant for the following terms and undertakings:

  • That the Registrant’s registration as a Full Pharmacist be suspended for a period of six (6) months, to commence on November 22, 2017;
  • That the Registrant pay a $10,000.00 fine to the College no later than November 22, 2018;
  • That a letter of reprimand be placed permanently on the College’s register;
  • That he appear before a panel of the Inquiry Committee for a verbal reprimand;
  • That he successfully complete the ProBE Program on Professional/Problem-Based Ethics for healthcare professionals no later than November 22, 2018; and
  • That he thoroughly review relevant legislation and complete the College’s Code of Ethics Educational Tutorial and sign declarations acknowledging his understanding and compliance with legislative and ethical requirements.
Pharmacist Registrant 33 (Sep 11, 2017)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 36 of the Health Professions Act, has reached an agreement with the pharmacist registrant to not engage in the practice of pharmacy. The agreement remains in effect until further notice. The Inquiry Committee considers the agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld pursuant to section 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.

Ratansi, Elishah (May 13, 2017)

Elishah Ratansi has satisfied terms of an agreement reached with the Inquiry Committee on July 6, 2015. Limits and conditions on the Elishah Ratansi’s registration as a pharmacist have now been removed.


August 12, 2016
(May 13, 2017 – Limits and conditions removed)

The Registration Committee has reinstated Ms. Ratansi’s registration as a Full/Active Pharmacist, effective August 12, 2016. Pursuant to a Consent Agreement signed on July 6, 2015, Ms. Ratansi agrees to the following limits and conditions on her practice, effective August 12, 2016:

  1. Prohibition from acting as a director for 9 months upon return to practice as a Full/Active Pharmacist; and
  2. Prohibition from acting as a pharmacy manager for 9 months upon return to practice as a Full/Active Pharmacist.

July 6, 2015
(August 12, 2016 – Registration reinstated)

Pursuant to section 36 of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached a Consent Agreement with Ms. Elishah Ratansi, effective July 6, 2015. This was the result of investigations conducted on a pharmacy under the management of Ms. Ratansi where several practice violations were allegedly found.  Also in the course of her employment as a pharmacist at the pharmacy in question, an illegal delivery scheme for transporting controlled substances was allegedly implemented by the management and pharmacy staff.  In light of the Inquiry Committee’s investigation and findings, Ms. Ratansi voluntarily placed her licence on non-practising status since January 1, 2015.  She agreed to the following terms in the Consent Agreement, among others:

  1. Suspension of registration as a pharmacist for six consecutive months, effective January 1, 2015. 
  2. Prohibition from acting as a director for 9 months upon return to practice as a Full/Active Pharmacist,
  3. Prohibition from acting as a pharmacy manager for 9 months upon return to practice as a Full/Active Pharmacist,
  4. Notification about this suspension will be published on the College website, pursuant to s. 39.3 of the Health Professions Act.

In the same Consent Agreement, Ms. Ratansi also agreed that she will not repeat the alleged conduct and to thoroughly review the legislation of which she was in breach.

Pharmacist Registrant 30 (May 1, 2017)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 36 of the Health Profession Act, has reached a new revised Agreement with the pharmacist registrant, whereby the Registrant consented to undertakings that include, but are not limited to:

  1. Complying with any and all treatment plans as recommended by the Registrant’s medical providers, including but not limited to the following:

    1. Regular and consistent attendance to the Registrant’s meetings with mental health team; and
       
    2. Adherence to medication regimen;

  2. Voluntarily stop working as a pharmacist and self-report to the College in the event that the Registrant’s medical condition may hinder performance and/or fitness to practice as a pharmacist;

The name of the Registrant has been withheld in accordance with section 39.3(4)(a) of the Health Professions Act for the purposes of not identifying the personal health information of the Registrant respecting the condition. The Inquiry Committee is satisfied that the undertakings will protect the public.


February 8, 2017
(May 1, 2017 - Limits and Conditions Revised)

The Inquiry Committee has reinstated pharmacist registrant’s registration which had previously been suspended for an indefinite period on December 23, 2016. Pursuant to section 36 of the Health Professions Act, the Inquiry Committee has reached an Agreement with the pharmacist registrant whereby the Registrant consented to undertakings involving regular monitoring for fitness to practice pharmacy. The undertakings include, but are not limited to:

  1. Complying with any and all treatment plans as recommended by the Registrant’s medical providers, including but not limited to the following:

    1. Regular and consistent attendance to meetings with the Registrant’s mental health team; and
       
    2. Adherence to medication regimen;

  2. That after returning to work in pharmacy setting, on every shift of employment at any pharmacy, the Registrant will work alongside another pharmacist in good standing at all times;

     

  3. That prior to the commencement of new employment at any pharmacy, the Registrant shall disclose to the pharmacy manager the limits and conditions of this Consent Agreement and ensure that arrangements are made in the pharmacy operations to accommodate the said limits and conditions:

    1. The Registrant must ensure that the pharmacy manager and/or employer with whom the Registrant secures employment submits a written statement to the College declaring:

      1. their awareness of the limits and conditions in; and
         
      2. their obligation to contact the College if they have questions or concerns about the Registrant’s practice. This statement must be received within 48 hours of any change of employment and/or 48 hours of any change in pharmacy manager/employer.

    2. The Registrant must inform a Complaints Officer in writing or via email of  places of employment as a pharmacist and report any changes of the location of employment within 72 hours of such change.

December 23, 2016
(February 8, 2017 – Registration reinstated)

The Inquiry Committee, pursuant to section 36 of the Health Professions Act, has reached an Agreement with the pharmacist registrant to suspend registration as a pharmacist, effective December 23, 2016. The Agreement remains in effect until further notice. The Inquiry Committee considers the Agreement necessary to protect the public. The pharmacist registrant's name has been withheld, pursuant to s. 39.3(4) of the Health Professions Act.

Pages